I've seen Slumdog Millionaire. I've seen Milk. I've seen The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. All are worthy contenders in the Best Picture race. None have me shouting in the streets.
For Your Consideration: Slumdog Millionaire, Best Achievement in Film Editing
Slumdog follows the rags to riches story of Jamal Malik, a contestant on the Indian version of Who Wants to be a Millionaire? who grew up in the slums of Mumbai. The film, which had virtually no buzz up until its release, is a triumph for director Danny Boyle. The story is layered with themes of greed, lust, and survival, and Boyle's choppy, raw editing complements the subject matter. I felt tense throughout the entire film, just like the characters on screen.
However, Slumdog is not a great film. It is measured, predictable, and delivers its messages with an iron fist. I generally prefer something a bit more subtle...like...Milk.
For Your Consideration: Milk, Best Actor: Sean Penn
Unlike Slumdog and to an extent Benjamin Button, Milk is a film that is driven by its actors. Slumdog is the Danny Boyle show, with fast and innovative direction. On the contrary, Milk is a character study in which Sean Penn delivers one of his greatest performances ever (and that is saying a lot). Harvey Milk was the first openly gay man to be elected to a public office in 1977. After only one year in office, he was assassinated. However, his legacy is not modest, and Gus Van Sant's film pays tribute to him beautifully.
Sean Penn is sensational in the title role. Once again, he transforms himself into his character, and I hardly recognize him. At this point, the only other performance I've heard such praise for is Rourke's in The Wrestler, which I have yet to see.
The supporting performances in Milk will probably be ignored by AMPAS, but they are worthy of mention. Josh Brolin seems to be getting a moderate amount of buzz, but I was most impressed by Emile Hirsch (who was snubbed last year for Into the Wild). James Franco was also fantastic in the role of Harvey's lover.
For Your Consideration: The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, Best Achievement in Makeup
In Benjamin Button, I have personally found my favorite film of the year. The screenplay was adapted from an F. Scott Fitzgerald short story by Eric Roth, who penned the 1994 film Forrest Gump. And not unlike Forrest Gump, Benjamin Button follows its title character from birth to death. However, in Benjamin's case, he is born an old man and "grows backwards." Brad Pitt plays Benjamin (and managed to surprise me on many levels), and Cate Blanchett plays his friend and lover, Daisy.
I went into this film with low expectations (this is NOT typical David Fincher), and I walked out thinking I'd just seen the most beautiful film ever put on screen. The aesthetics of the film were spot on. Makeup, Cinematography, and Art Direction are all locked in. Pitt and Blanchett both deliver fantastic performances, but the film is really all about soft, subtle direction and a beautiful story. Fincher and Roth should both be rewarded, but they do face some tough competition in their categories.
At this point, I'd say all three of these films are in for Best Picture. And if I have to call it this early, it's going to be The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.


