I know I'm not the only one who, rather baselessly, declared that Avatar would disappoint us. I thought Cameron's Avatar would fall completely on its $300 mil ass. But I'm pleased to say that I left the theater this morning swelling with emotion; it is truly a film experience like nothing you've seen before.
Cameron's Avatar pulls you into the mysterious world of his own creation, Pandora. The only production that slightly compares is Peter Jackson's Middle Earth from The Lord of the Rings (which was designed by WETA, who also worked on Avatar's visuals and miniatures). Really, I haven't felt the same magic in watching film since Lord of the Rings; Avatar shares that same innovation.
The film, rather surprisingly, offers some great acting amid all the production and visual effects. This is an accomplishment on any film that employs a heavy amount of CGI or green screen, because it's hard for actors to connect with technology in the same way that they do other human beings. Sure, Sam Worthington's Australian accent peeks through on occasion and Sigourney Weaver's dialogue delivery is at times cringe-worthy, but overall they held it together in a way that is ordinarily not possible in such a heavily produced film.
The criticism towards Avatar is mostly fixated on the story, and while I won't make a case for James Cameron's writing here (was he ever really on anyone's list for a Screenplay nomination?), I will say that his story has extraordinary imagination. I agree that the dialogue was, at times, like watching an episode of Lois and Clark, but it didn't hurt the experience for me (I also don't want to rehash the same things you've already read). My complaints mostly have to do with the last act, and I don't want to spoil it here, so we'll just let that go.
I can't remember the last time I felt that Best Picture was so tight, and Avatar is very much in the running at this point. As we're moving towards the guild recognition part of the season, we may get some more insight. But really, I hope it stays this unpredictable.






